Tributary Benthic Invertebrates, Oil Sands Region

Tributary Biomonitoring (Lower Athabasca River)

           Benthic macroinvertebrates, comprising insects, crusteaceans, molluscs and worms, represent a group of organisms used widely in environmental monitoring programs as early warning indicators to assess the effects of change in water quality or physical habitat conditions on aquatic ecosystem health.


           An interpretive report (Culp et. al., 2018) was released in 2018 which included assessments of the benthic and supporting data from 2012-2015. An excerpt from the executive summary regarding the tributary  benthic invertebrate results is provided below and the full report can be found online at https://open.alberta.ca/publications/9781460140314.


           “Biomonitoring of the LAR tributaries revealed benthic assemblages associated with good ecological condition (i.e., dominated by intolerant taxa). However, assemblages in areas with increased human disturbance exhibited divergence from reference sites and this trend may be associated with mild environmental stress. Moreover, in the Steepbank and Ells rivers, the composition of benthic assemblage was associated with gradients in catchment disturbance and PAC concentration.

           Further investigation is required to determine whether there is a causal relationship between exposure to environmental stressors and altered assemblage composition. Across LAR tributaries, future change in benthic assemblages will be examined through development of a Reference ConditionApproach model against which test sites can be compared to determine divergence from reference sites. Comparative analyses demonstrate that kick net sampling provides higher resolution taxonomic information compared to the Hess sampling method, and ongoing assessments should employ the kick net sampling approach. Core monitoring of 15 reference and 10 test sites should be completed annually with an additional five reference and five test sites sampled on a rotational basis. New sites in the mineable area may be required to address data gaps for reference sites as well as additional sites near development boundaries. Finally, assessments are underway to relate historical data collected by the Regional Aquatic Monitoring Program (RAMP) to current JOSM data.”


           Biomonitoring Water Quality


           In addition to collecting benthic invertebrate samples, supporting water chemistry samples were taken on the same date.


           Verified and validated water quality data from fall of 2011 through to the fall of 2017 collected to support Invertebrate and Ecosystem Health studies. Data was collected at up to twenty-one sites on the mainstem of the Athabasca River and over 100 sites on its major tributaries.


           The data include measures of nutrients, metals (dissolved and total), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and major ions.

Supplemental Information

Culp, J. C., Glozier, N. E., Baird D. J., Baird, Wrona, F. J., Brua, R. B., Ritcey A. L., Peters D. L., Casey.R., Choung, C. B., Curry, C. J., Halliwell, D., Keet, E., Kilgour, B., Kirk, J., Lento, J., Luiker, E. & C. Suzanne. 2018. Assessing ecosystem health in benthic macroinvertebrate assemblages of the athabasca river main stem, tributaries, and peace-athabasca delta. Oil Sands Monitoring Technical Report Series No. 1.7. 82 p. June 2018

https://open.alberta.ca/publications/9781460140314

Supporting Projects: Canada-Alberta Oil Sands Environmental Monitoring

           Benthic macroinvertebrates, comprising insects, crusteaceans, molluscs and worms, represent a group of organisms used widely in environmental monitoring programs as early warning indicators to assess the effects of change in water quality or physical habitat conditions on aquatic ecosystem health.


           An interpretive report (Culp et. al., 2018) was released in 2018 which included assessments of the benthic and supporting data from 2012-2015. An excerpt from the executive summary regarding the tributary  benthic invertebrate results is provided below and the full report can be found online at https://open.alberta.ca/publications/9781460140314.


           “Biomonitoring of the LAR tributaries revealed benthic assemblages associated with good ecological condition (i.e., dominated by intolerant taxa). However, assemblages in areas with increased human disturbance exhibited divergence from reference sites and this trend may be associated with mild environmental stress. Moreover, in the Steepbank and Ells rivers, the composition of benthic assemblage was associated with gradients in catchment disturbance and PAC concentration.

           Further investigation is required to determine whether there is a causal relationship between exposure to environmental stressors and altered assemblage composition. Across LAR tributaries, future change in benthic assemblages will be examined through development of a Reference ConditionApproach model against which test sites can be compared to determine divergence from reference sites. Comparative analyses demonstrate that kick net sampling provides higher resolution taxonomic information compared to the Hess sampling method, and ongoing assessments should employ the kick net sampling approach. Core monitoring of 15 reference and 10 test sites should be completed annually with an additional five reference and five test sites sampled on a rotational basis. New sites in the mineable area may be required to address data gaps for reference sites as well as additional sites near development boundaries. Finally, assessments are underway to relate historical data collected by the Regional Aquatic Monitoring Program (RAMP) to current JOSM data.”


           Biomonitoring Water Quality


           In addition to collecting benthic invertebrate samples, supporting water chemistry samples were taken on the same date.


           Verified and validated water quality data from fall of 2011 through to the fall of 2017 collected to support Invertebrate and Ecosystem Health studies. Data was collected at up to twenty-one sites on the mainstem of the Athabasca River and over 100 sites on its major tributaries.


           The data include measures of nutrients, metals (dissolved and total), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and major ions.

Please login or register to comment.